Guide
Mutations and appraising
The Appraiser rerolls a fish's mutation and weight for a fee. Here are the real odds of each roll.
Our take
Appraising is a gamble on fish that are already worth a lot. Use it on rare catches, never on commons, and keep anything that already has a top-paying mutation.
Odds per appraisal
- 7%Mutation
- 13%Weight boost
- 1%Shiny
- 1%Sparkling
Base chances from the game's appraisal code, before events and weather that raise them.
Mutations you'll see most
| Mutation | Per appraisal | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Albino | 0.63% | ×1.5 |
| Darkened | 0.63% | ×1.5 |
| Negative | 0.63% | ×1.3 |
| Glossy | 0.53% | ×1.6 |
| Bioluminescent | 0.42% | ×6 |
| Lunar | 0.42% | ×2.5 |
| Translucent | 0.42% | ×1.3 |
| Electric | 0.32% | ×2.1 |
The best-paying ones
Before you appraise
- The Appraiser stands in Moosewood Village.
- Appraising rerolls weight and mutation as if you caught the fish again.
- Each appraisal costs part of the fish's current value.
- Shiny and Sparkling never get removed.
- Surge events help appraisal odds, rod abilities do not.
Mutation basics
- A mutation changes a fish's look and sell value.
- A fish holds one mutation at a time.
- Some rods give a mutation often, like the Midas Rod.
- Some mutations only come from certain weather or events.
- Appraising rerolls the mutation.